The 'Healthy Worker Effect' on Indexes of Total Mortality and Malignant Neoplasms Mortality for Nuclear and Chemical Workers: Meta-Analysis

Cover Page

Cite item

Full Text

Abstract

A meta-analysis of studies of the ‘Standardized mortality ratio’ (SMR, in % compared with the general population) indexes of overall mortality and mortality from all malignant neoplasms for nuclear workers (NW) from 15 countries (for 2007), as well as for workers dealing with the most toxic heavy metals (Hg, Cd, Pb, Cu) and beta-naphthylamine (a carcinogenic antioxidant previously used in the manufacture of paints) was carried out. For NW, a ‘Healthy worker effect’ (HWE) was found for both indexes (SMR = 62 (95 % CI: 56; 69) and 74 (95 % CI: 69; 78), respectively). The obtained SMR values for NW were compared with data for other professional groups (the results of meta-analyses and individual studies with maximum and minimum SMR values: from cosmonauts/astronauts, pilots and athletes, to work with chemical compounds in general or with their individual types (solvents, heavy metals, beta-naphthylamine), as well as with asbestos. It was found that the level of HWE for NW is comparable to that for one group of athletes and is significantly (1.30–1.45 times) higher than for chemical production personnel, although the combined data for NW is not final.

For workers in the chemical industry as a whole, according to published meta-analyses, HWE was also found in SMR, but weak: the value for total mortality was 90 (95 % CI: 87; 92). At the same time, mortality from all malignant neoplasms compared with the population did not reveal a clear HWE, but was not increased either. The most harmful types of employment are, on the rise, work with heavy metals, in coal mines, with beta-naphthylamine and with asbestos.

The data obtained eliminates the prevailing stereotypes and can improve the image of employment in the nuclear and chemical industries in general.

About the authors

A. N. Koterov

A.I. Burnazyan Federal Medical Biophysical Center

Email: govorilga@inbox.ru
Moscow

L. N. Ushenkova

A.I. Burnazyan Federal Medical Biophysical Center

Email: govorilga@inbox.ru
Moscow

M. V. Kalinina

A.I. Burnazyan Federal Medical Biophysical Center

Email: govorilga@inbox.ru
Moscow

A. P. Biryukov

A.I. Burnazyan Federal Medical Biophysical Center

Email: govorilga@inbox.ru
Moscow

References

  1. Monson R.R. Observations on the Healthy Worker Effect. J. Occup. Med. 1986;28;6:425–433. https://doi.org/10.1097/00043764-198606000-00009.
  2. Ogle W. Letter to the Registrar-General on the Mortality in the Registration Districts of England and Wales During the Ten Years 1871–80. Supplement to the 45th Annual Report of the Registrar-General of Births, Deaths, and Marriages, in England. London, 1885. P. 23.
  3. McMichael A.J., Spirtas R., Kupper L.L. An Epidemiologic Study of Mortality Within a Cohort of Rubber Workers, 1964–72. J. Occup. Med. 1974;16;7:458–464.
  4. Trubetskov A.D., Zhirov K.S. ‘The Effect of Healthy Worker’ in Various Areas of Occupational Medicine: the Publications Review. Problemy Sotsialnoy Gigiyeny, Zdravookhraneniya i Istorii Meditsiny = Problems of Social Hygiene, Public Health and History of Medicine. 2021;29;2:254–259. https://doi.org/10.32687/0869-866X-2021-29-2-254-259 (In Russ.).
  5. Demographic and Social Statistics T.5. Entsiklopediya statisticheskikh terminov. V 8-mi t. = Encyclopedia of Statistical Terms. In 8 Volumes. Moscow Publ., 2011. 482 p. (In Russ.).
  6. Samorodskaya I.V., Semenov V.Yu. Malignant Neoplasms Mortality Rates in Moscow and Saint Petersburg in 2015 and 2018. Sovremennaya Onkologiya = Journal of Modern Oncology. 2020;22;3:79–84. https://doi.org/10.26442/18151434.2020.3.200192 (In Russ.).
  7. Drapkina O.M., Samorodskaya I.V., Bolotova E.V., Dudnikova A.V. Analysis of the Dynamics of Mortality from Respiratory Diseases in the Russian Federation for 2019–2020. Terapevticheskiy Arkhiv = Therapeutic Archive. 2022;94;3:401–408. https://doi.org/10.26442/00403660.2022.03.201403 (In Russ.).
  8. Tikhonova G.I., Piktushanskaya T.E., Gorchakova T.Yu., Churanova A.N., Bryleva M.S. Influence of Duration and Intensity of Exposure to Occupational Hazards on Mortality Levels of Coal Miners. Meditsina Truda i Promyshlennaya Ekologiya = Russian Journal of Occupational Health and Industrial Ecology. 2018;7:16–21. https://doi.org/10.31089/1026-9428-2021-61-9-580-587(In Russ.).
  9. Mastrangelo G., Marzia V., Marcer G. Reduced Lung Cancer Mortality in Dairy Farmers: is Endotoxin Exposure the Key Factor? Am. J. Ind. Med. 1996;30;5:601–609. https://doi.org/110.1002/(SICI)1097-0274(199611)30:5<601::AID-AJIM8>3.0.CO;2-V.
  10. A Dictionary of Epidemiology. Ed. Last J.M. Oxford, Oxford University Press, 2001.
  11. Vlasov V.V. Epidemiologiya = Epidemiology. Textbook. Moscow, GEOTAR-Media Publ., 2006. 464 p. (In Russ.).
  12. Guidelines for the Development of Regional Demographic Development Programs. Moscow Publ., 2012. 50 p. (In Russ.).
  13. Fox A.J., Collier P.F. Low Mortality Rates in Industrial Cohort Studies Due to Selection for Work and Survival in the Industry. Br. J. Prev. Soc. Med. 1976;30;4:225–230. https://doi.org/10.1136/jech.30.4.225.
  14. Wen C.P., Tsai S.P., Gibson R.L. Anatomy of the Healthy Worker Effect: a Critical Review. J. Occup. Med. 1983;25;4:283–289.
  15. Sheikh K. A Review of the Healthy Worker Effect in Occupational Epidemiology. Occup. Med. (Lond). 2000;50;2:146. https://doi.org/10.1093/occmed/50.2.146.
  16. Roessler M. Can We Trust the Standardized Mortality Ratio? A Formal Analysis and Evaluation Based on Axiomatic Requirements. PLoS One. 2021;16;9:e0257003. https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0257003.
  17. Gaffey W.R. A Critique of the Standardized Mortality Ratio. J. Occup. Med. 1976;18;3:157–160. https://doi.org/10.1097/00043764-197603000-00007.
  18. Monson R.R. Observations on the Healthy Worker Effect. J. Occup. Med. 1986;28;6:425–433. https://doi.org/10.1097/00043764-198606000-00009.
  19. Guidotti T.L. The Handbook of Occupational and Environmental Medicine: Principles, Practice, and Problem-Solving. In 2 Volumes. Praeger-ABC-CLIO, LLC. 2020. 1212 p.
  20. Metz-Flamant C., Rogel A., Caer S., Samson E., Laurier D., Acker A., Tirmarche M. Mortality among Workers Monitored for Radiation Exposure at the French Nuclear Fuel Company. Arch. Environ Occup. Health. 2009;64;4:242–250. https://doi.org/10.1080/19338240903348246.
  21. Bond G.G., Bodner K.M., Olsen G.W., Cook R.R. Mortality among Workers Engaged in the Development or Manufacture of Styrene-Based Products: an Update. Scand J. Work Environ Health. 1992;18;3:145–154. https://doi.org/10.5271/sjweh.1594.
  22. Beckman I.N. Yadernaya Industriya = Nuclear Industry. Lecture Course. Moscow Publ., 2005. 867 p. (In Russ.).
  23. Kirkeleit J., Riise T., Bjorge T., Christiani D.C. The Healthy Worker Effect in Cancer Incidence Studies. Am. J. Epidemiol. 2013;177;11:1218–1224. https://doi.org/10.1093/aje/kws373.
  24. Breslow N.E., Day N.E. Statistical Methods in Cancer Research. V.II. The Design and Analysis of Cohort Studies. Lyon, World Health Organization, 1987. P. 17–20.
  25. Carpenter L.M. Some Observations on the Healthy Worker Effect. Br. J. Ind. Med. 1987;44;5:289–291. https://doi.org/10.1136/oem.44.5.289.
  26. Li C.Y., Sung F.C. A Review of the Healthy Worker Effect in Occupational Epidemiology. Occup. Med. (Lond). 1999;49;4:225–229. https://doi.org/10.1093/occmed/49.4.225.
  27. Koshurnikova N.A., Buldakov L.A., Bysogolov G.D., Bolotnikova M.G., Komleva N.S., Peternikova V.S. Mortality from Malignancies of the Hematopoietic and Lymphatic Tissues among Personnel of the First Nuclear Plant in the USSR. Sci. Total. Environ. 1994;142;1–2:19–23. https://doi.org/10.1016/0048-9697(94)90068-x.
  28. Koshurnikova N.A., Bolotnikova M.G., Gruzdeva E.A., Kabirova N.R., Kreslov V.V., Okatenko P.V., et al. Late Effects of Occupational Radiation Exposure (Mortality in Personnel of ‘Mayak’ Complex for 45 Years of Follow-Up). Radiatsiya i Risk = Radiation and Risk. 1995;5:137–44 (In Russ.).
  29. Koshurnikova N.A., Bysogolov G.D., Bolotnikova M.G., Khokhryakov V.F., Kreslov V.V., Okatenko P.V. et al. Mortality among Personnel who Worked at the Mayak Complex in the First Years of Its Operation. Health Phys. 1996;71;1:90–93. https://doi.org/10.1097/00004032-199607000-00015.
  30. Koshurnikova N.A., Okatenko P.V., Sokolnikov M.E., Vasilenko E.K., Khokhryakov V.V. Medical Consequences of the Professional Exposure: Carcinogenic Risk in the Cohort of ‘Mayak’ PA Workers. Medits. Meditsinskaya Radiologiya i Radiatsionnaya Bezopasnost = Medical Radiology and Radiation Safety. 2008;53;3:23–33 (In Russ.).
  31. Azizova T.V., Batistatou E., Grigorieva E.S., et al. An Assessment of Radiation-Associated Risks of Mortality from Circulatory Disease in the Cohorts of Mayak and Sellafield Nuclear Workers. Radiat. Res. 2018;189;4:371–388. https://doi.org/10.1667/RR14468.1.
  32. Greenberg R.S., Mandel J.S., Pastides H., Britton N.L., Rudenko L., Starr T.B. A Meta-Analysis of Cohort Studies Describing Mortality and Cancer Incidence among Chemical Workers in the United States and Western Europe. Epidemiology. 2001;12;6:727–740. https://doi.org/10.1097/00001648-200111000-00023.
  33. Chen R., Seaton A. A Meta-Analysis of Mortality among Workers Exposed to Organic Solvents. Occup. Med. 1996;46:337–344. https://doi.org/10.1093/occmed/46.5.337.
  34. Rothman K.J. Cancer Occurrence among Workers Exposed to Acrylonitrile. Scand. J. Work Environ Health. 1994;20;5:313–321. doi: 10.5271/sjweh.1391.
  35. Alder N., Fenty J., Warren F., et al. Meta-Analysis of Mortality and Cancer Incidence among Workers in the Synthetic Rubber-Producing Industry. Am. J. Epidemiol. 2006;164;5:405–420. https://doi.org/10.1093/aje/kwj252.
  36. Morfeld P., Mundt K.A., Dell L.D., Sorahan T., McCunney R.J. Meta-Analysis of Cardiac Mortality in Three Cohorts of Carbon Black Production Workers. Int. J. Environ Res. Public. Health. 2016;13;3:302. doi: 10.3390/ijerph13030302.
  37. Vrijheid M., Cardis E., Blettner M., Gilbert E., Hakama M., Hill C., et al. The 15-Country Collaborative Study of Cancer Risk Among Radiation Workers in the Nuclear Industry: Design, Epidemiological Methods and Descriptive Results. Radiat. Res. 2007;167;4:361–379. https://doi.org/10.1667/RR0554.1.
  38. Cassidy L.D., Youk A.O., Marsh G.M. The Drake Health Registry Study: Cause-Specific Mortality Experience of Workers Potentially Exposed to Beta-Naphthylamine. Am. J. Ind. Med. 2003;44;3:282–290. https://doi.org/10.1002/ajim.10268.
  39. Higgins J.P., Thompson S.G., Deeks J.J., Altman D.G. Measuring Inconsistency in Meta-Analyses. Brit. Med. J. 2003;327;7414:557–560. https://doi.org/10.1136/bmj.327.7414.557.
  40. Blettner M., Sauerbrei W., Schlehofer B., Scheuchenpflug T., Friedenreich C. Traditional Reviews, Meta-Analyses and Pooled Analyses in Epidemiology. Int. J. Epidemiol. 1999;28;1:1–9. https://doi.org/10.1093/ije/28.1.1.
  41. Sterne J.A., Egger M., Smith G.D. Systematic Reviews in Health Care: Investigating and Dealing with Publication and Other Biases in Meta-Analysis. Br. Med. J. 2001;323;7304:101–105. https://doi.org/10.1136/bmj.323.7304.101.
  42. Axelson O. Negative and Non-Positive Epidemiological Studies. Int. J. Occup. Med. Environ. Health. 2004;17;1:115–121.
  43. Gerosa A., Ietri E., Belli S., Grignoli M., Comba P. High Risk of Pleural Mesothelioma among the State Railroad Carriage Repair Workers. Epidemiol. Prev. 2000;24;3:117–119 (In Italian.).
  44. Miller B.G., MacCalman L. Cause-Specific Mortality in British Coal Workers and Exposure to Respirable Dust and Quartz. Occup. Environ. Med. 2010;67;4:270–276. https://doi.org/10.1136/oem.2009.046151.
  45. Nakashima E., Neriishi K., Minamoto A. A Reanalysis of Atomic-Bomb Cataract Data, 2000–2002: a Threshold Analysis. Health Phys. 2006;90;2:154–160. https://doi.org/10.1097/01.hp.0000175442.03596.63.
  46. Neriishi K., Nakashima E., Minamoto A., Fujiwara S., Akahoshi M., Mishima H.K., et al. Postoperative Cataract Cases among Atomic Bomb Survivors: Radiation Dose Response and Threshold. Radiat. Res. 2007;168;4:404–408. https://doi.org/10.1667/RR0928.1.
  47. Juel K. High Mortality in the Thule Cohort: an Unhealthy Worker Effect. Int. J. Epidemiol. 1994;23;6:1174–1178. https://doi.org/10.1093/ije/23.6.1174.
  48. Ushakov I.B., Voronkov Y.I., Bukhtiyarov I.V. Tikhonova G.I., Gorchakova T.Yu., Bryleva M.S. A Cohort Mortality Study among Soviet and Russian Cosmonauts, 1961–2014. Aerosp. Med. Hum. Perform. 2017;88;12:1060–1065. https://doi.org/10.3357/AMHP.4701.2017.
  49. Reynolds R.J., Day S.M. Mortality of US Astronauts: Comparisons with Professional Athletes. Occup. Environ. Med. 2019;76;2:114–117. https://doi.org/10.1136/oemed-2018-105304.
  50. Gajewski A.K., Poznanska A. Mortality of Top Athletes, Actors and Clergy in Poland: 1924-2000 Follow-Up Study of the Long Term Effect of Physical Activity. Eur. J. Epidemiol. 2008;23;5:335–340. https://doi.org/10.1007/s10654-008-9237-3.
  51. Hammer G.P., Auvinen A., De Stavola B.L., Grajewski B., Gundestrup M., Haldorsen T., et al. Mortality from Cancer and Other Causes in Commercial Airline Crews: a Joint Analysis of Cohorts from 10 Countries. Occup. Environ. Med. 2014;71;5:313–322. https://doi.org/10.1136/oemed-2013-101395.
  52. McLaughlin R., Nielsen L., Waller M. An Evaluation of the Effect of Military Service on Mortality: Quantifying the Healthy Soldier Effect. Ann. Epidemiol. 2008;18;12:928–936. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.annepidem.2008.09.002.
  53. Alif S.M., Sim M.R., Ho C., Glass D.C. Cancer and Mortality in Coal Mine Workers: a Systematic Review and Meta-Analysis. Occup. Environ. Med. 2022;79;5:347–357. https://doi.org/10.1136/oemed-2021-107498.
  54. Luberto F., Ferrante D., Silvestri S., Angelini A., Cuccaro F., Nannavecchia A.M., et al. Cumulative Asbestos Exposure and Mortality from Asbestos Related Diseases in a Pooled Analysis of 21 Asbestos Cement Cohorts in Italy. Environ Health. 2019;18;1:71. https://doi.org/10.1186/s12940-019-0510-6.
  55. Piolatto G., Negri E., La Vecchia C., Pira E., Decarli A., Peto J. An Update of Cancer Mortality among Chrysotile Asbestos Miners in Balangero, Northern Italy. Br. J. Ind. Med. 1990;47;12:810–814. https://doi.org/10.1136/oem.47.12.810.
  56. Dement J.M., Harris R.L.Jr., Symons M.J., Shy C.M. Exposures and Mortality among Chrysotile Asbestos Workers. Part II: Mortality. Am. J. Ind. Med. 1983;4;3:421–433. https://doi.org/10.1002/ajim.4700040304.
  57. Duffus J.H. ‘Heavy Metals’— a Meaningless Term? Pure and Applied Chemistry. 2002:74;5:793–807. http://dx.doi.org/10.1351/pac200274050793.
  58. Srivastava N.K., Majumder C.B. Novel Biofiltration Methods for the Treatment of Heavy Metals from Industrial Wastewater. J. Hazard Mater. 2008;151;1:1–8. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jhazmat.2007.09.101.
  59. Koterov A.N., Ushenkova L.N., Kalinina M.V., Biryukov A.P. Brief Review of World Researches of Radiation and Non-Radiation Effects in Nuclear Industry Workers. Mediko-Biologicheskiye Problemy Zhiznedeyatelnosti = Medical and Biological Problems of Life Activity. 2020;1:17–31 (In Russ.).
  60. Skriver M.V., Vaeth M., Stovring H. Loss of Life Expectancy Derived from a Standardized Mortality Ratio in Denmark, Finland, Norway and Sweden. Scand. J. Public Health. 2018;46;7:767–773. https://doi.org/10.1177/1403494817749050.
  61. Tsai S.P., Hardy R.J., Wen C.P. The Standardized Mortality Ratio and Life Expectancy. Am. J. Epidemiol. 1992;135;7:824–831. https://doi.org/10.1093/oxfordjournals.aje.a116369.
  62. Lai D., Guo F., Hardy R.J. Standardized Mortality Ratio and Life Expectancy: a Comparative Study of Chinese Mortality. Int. J. Epidemiol. 2000;29;5:852–855. https://doi.org/10.1093/ije/29.5.852.
  63. DeVivo M.J, Savic G., Frankel H.L., Jamous M.A., Soni B.M., Charlifue S., et al. Comparison of Statistical Methods for Calculating Life Expectancy after Spinal Cord Injury. Spinal Cord. 2018;56;7:666–673. https://doi.org/10.1038/s41393-018-0067-1.
  64. Lutz W., Striessnig E., Dimitrova A., Ghislandi S., Lijadi A., Reiter C., et al. Years of Good Life Is a Well-Being Indicator Designed to Serve Research on Sustainability. Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. USA. 2021;118;12:e1907351118. https://doi.org/10.1073/pnas.1907351118.

Supplementary files

Supplementary Files
Action
1. JATS XML
Download

Согласие на обработку персональных данных с помощью сервиса «Яндекс.Метрика»

1. Я (далее – «Пользователь» или «Субъект персональных данных»), осуществляя использование сайта https://journals.rcsi.science/ (далее – «Сайт»), подтверждая свою полную дееспособность даю согласие на обработку персональных данных с использованием средств автоматизации Оператору - федеральному государственному бюджетному учреждению «Российский центр научной информации» (РЦНИ), далее – «Оператор», расположенному по адресу: 119991, г. Москва, Ленинский просп., д.32А, со следующими условиями.

2. Категории обрабатываемых данных: файлы «cookies» (куки-файлы). Файлы «cookie» – это небольшой текстовый файл, который веб-сервер может хранить в браузере Пользователя. Данные файлы веб-сервер загружает на устройство Пользователя при посещении им Сайта. При каждом следующем посещении Пользователем Сайта «cookie» файлы отправляются на Сайт Оператора. Данные файлы позволяют Сайту распознавать устройство Пользователя. Содержимое такого файла может как относиться, так и не относиться к персональным данным, в зависимости от того, содержит ли такой файл персональные данные или содержит обезличенные технические данные.

3. Цель обработки персональных данных: анализ пользовательской активности с помощью сервиса «Яндекс.Метрика».

4. Категории субъектов персональных данных: все Пользователи Сайта, которые дали согласие на обработку файлов «cookie».

5. Способы обработки: сбор, запись, систематизация, накопление, хранение, уточнение (обновление, изменение), извлечение, использование, передача (доступ, предоставление), блокирование, удаление, уничтожение персональных данных.

6. Срок обработки и хранения: до получения от Субъекта персональных данных требования о прекращении обработки/отзыва согласия.

7. Способ отзыва: заявление об отзыве в письменном виде путём его направления на адрес электронной почты Оператора: info@rcsi.science или путем письменного обращения по юридическому адресу: 119991, г. Москва, Ленинский просп., д.32А

8. Субъект персональных данных вправе запретить своему оборудованию прием этих данных или ограничить прием этих данных. При отказе от получения таких данных или при ограничении приема данных некоторые функции Сайта могут работать некорректно. Субъект персональных данных обязуется сам настроить свое оборудование таким способом, чтобы оно обеспечивало адекватный его желаниям режим работы и уровень защиты данных файлов «cookie», Оператор не предоставляет технологических и правовых консультаций на темы подобного характера.

9. Порядок уничтожения персональных данных при достижении цели их обработки или при наступлении иных законных оснований определяется Оператором в соответствии с законодательством Российской Федерации.

10. Я согласен/согласна квалифицировать в качестве своей простой электронной подписи под настоящим Согласием и под Политикой обработки персональных данных выполнение мною следующего действия на сайте: https://journals.rcsi.science/ нажатие мною на интерфейсе с текстом: «Сайт использует сервис «Яндекс.Метрика» (который использует файлы «cookie») на элемент с текстом «Принять и продолжить».